THE BUTTONWOOD FARM

39 Acres

1505 W Kings Hwy, Gap, PA 17527, USA

Auction Date: September 22, 2026 6:00 pm
Open House: August 4, 2026 4:00 pm (2 Hours)
2nd Open House:September 2, 2026 4:00 pm (2 Hours)

Sellers: Elam S. and Anna Mae Riehl
Starting Bid: $750,000
Down Payment: $85,000 due day of sale.
Settlement on or before: November 20, 2026

Download Brochure

39+/- Acres… Showcasing the Best of Lancaster County!

This farm begs your attention! Your family will enjoy the endless opportunities with the acreage, livestock potential, and the elegantly finished living areas that make hosting a breeze. The fully restored 1700’s house is truly the Sizzle on the Steak!

Elegantly Restored 1700’s Mansion
Unique features throughout such as:
Extra wide 44″ front door, bubble glass,
Indian door, full slab windowpanes
5 stone fireplaces
Beautiful cherry kitchen with island – Wow!
Restored 1700’s fireplace with real cast iron swinging kettle
Parlor with fireplace
4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
Master bed with attached bath with jacuzzi
Full basement, fully finished – Children Love This Playroom!
Man cave and hunting room
Brand new A.C.
Central vacuum
Floor heat on 2 floors
New auto back-up boiler

In-law Residence – Remodeled in 2009
Lots of hosting space
Kitchen with modern feel
Lots of countertop and island
Appliances, washer, dryer included
2 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms
Comfy living room
Office/study
2nd story balcony
Brand new A.C.
Central vacuum
Oversized 1 car attached garage
Separate driveway
Beautiful lawn with mature trees

Bankbarn and Garage Bays
5 garage bays for equipment storage
Plenty of hay storage
6 horse stalls with adjustable dividers
Auto waterers
Tackroom

Beautifully Finished Rec-room
Radiant floor heat
Host the whole family
Full kitchen – range included
1 restroom
Central vacuum

Workshop and Garage
Workbench and tool storage
2 car garage
Fully wired, 220V power
Honan Diesel provides backup power
to whole farm
25KW generator – manual start

Hard to find acreage
Location with multiple possibilities
20 acres currently tillable
18 acres pasture (most could be tillable)
2 creeks for irrigation
Animal lovers’ paradise
Fences and arena
Watch animals graze from patio
Dog kennel/chicken house combo

Meticulously Maintained Farm
Paved driveway
Large lawn for recreation
New in-ground dog fence
Backyard stone patio
Wraparound front porch
2nd story balcony
Wood Master boiler provides all heating
Martin’s Water system

See More Upcoming Auctions

York City 2-Unit Investment

Auction Date: August 14, 2026 6:00 pm
701 West Princess Street, York, PA, USA

Fully Tenant Occupied Unit 1Recently UpdatedKitchen with Appliances2 Bedrooms – 1 BathLiving Room / Dining RoomFront and Back PorchesVinyl Replacement WindowsElectric Baseboard Heat Unit 2Kitchen with Appliances3 Bedrooms – 1 BathDining Room with Bay WindowsLiving Room with FireplaceFront and Back PorchesSecond-Floor BalconyElectric Baseboard Heat Investment Highlights$29,940 Yearly IncomeOff-Street ParkingSolid Brick StructureFully Tenant OccupiedConvenient Corner LotUpscale […]

The Ephrata Cottage

Auction Date: July 29, 2026 6:00 pm
0.15 acres
216 West Fulton Street, Ephrata, PA, USA

Local Investment – Fully Occupied – Well maintained – Offstreet Parking – Nice Backyard 216 – Unit A Clean InteriorGreat Condition2 beds, 1 bathPartial hardwood flooringBeautiful front porchFull basementAll appliances includedWasher and dryerCentral Heating and cooling 216 – Unit B Well maintained1 bed, 1 bathAppealing kitchen cabinetsPorch overlooks backyardAll appliances includedWasher and dryerElectric Baseboard heat […]

Unique Homestead

Auction Date: July 22, 2026 6:00 pm
.83 acres
6086 Old Philadelphia Pike Gap, PA 17527

With Private In-Law Quarters House Marked by Abundant Detail: Porch/MudroomCustom Built Kitchen — Updated Modern AppealComplete with All AppliancesDining Room with Lots of WindowsLarge Comfy Living RoomPrivate OfficeOpen Stairway4 Upstairs Bedrooms2nd Floor BalconyBasement with Can ShelvesPropane Furnace/Forced Air Heat Recently Remodeled In-Law Quarters: 1 BedroomFull BathCozy KitchenSeparate Entrance Additional Benefits8×10 Garden Shed500-Gallon Propane TankLarge Backyard […]

Pequea Valley Vista

Auction Date: September 1, 2026 6:00 pm
.86 acres
285 School Lane Rd, Gap, PA, USA

5 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom HomeLarge Eat-In KitchenLiving Room with Bay WindowsSewing Room / OfficeBonus Guest RoomOpen Floor PlanWraparound DeckFront PorchPartially Finished BasementCold Cellar with Shelves4′ × 6′ Walk-In CoolerHot Water HeaterCrown Propane Boiler Horse Barn32′ × 64′ Horse Barn and Shop5 Large Horse Stalls12′ × 32′ Shop AreaFull Second-Floor Recreation Room with RestroomDiesel / Utility […]

Kinzer Road Duplex

Auction Date: July 28, 2026 6:00 pm
0.33 acres
14-16 N Kinzer Rd, Kinzers, PA, USA

Excellent Investment in a Prime Location 2-Unit Investment Property Property Highlights & Advantages:

The Fabulous Five

Auction Date: August 7, 2026 6:00 pm
5.26 acres
257 Hill Rd, New Holland, PA, USA

Immaculate Homestead on the Welsh Mountain! Family Sized Home New in 2001Mudroom and LaundryWide Open floor spaceLiving room with patio accessDining room with porch accessStudy and sewing room5 bedrooms, 2 bathroomsLarge master bedroomOpen stairway to second storyFinished basement with kitchenCold CellarLots of storage space Three Story Horsebarn New in 2001Main level has:Forebay and 4 stallsSeparate […]